On “Almonds Don’t Lactate” Anniversary, Dairy Farmers Call on FDA To Do Its Job

ARLINGTON, Va. – The National Milk Producers Federation today marked the one-year anniversary of then-FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb’s famous observation that “almonds don’t lactate” by reminding the agency it still has not resolved the issue and that citizens who heeded its call for comments with thoughtful responses deserve answers.

“An almond doesn’t lactate, I must confess,” Gottlieb said last July 17, admitting that FDA has been lax in enforcing its own rules on the use of dairy terms on products containing no dairy ingredients. “Have we been enforcing our standard of identity? The answer is, probably not,” he said, while pledging agency action in “something close to a year.”

“FDA’s longstanding inaction on enforcing its own standards of identity is perpetuating the marketing of products using milk and dairy terms when those products don’t match the nutritional content of the dairy products they are imitating,” said Jim Mulhern, president and CEO of NMPF. “Dairy farmers have never called for bans on fake-food competitors, nor have they called for market censorship. They do want the FDA to enforce its own rules defining what a product is and what it isn’t, in keeping with similar standards enforced in other countries around the globe. The clock is still ticking. We are not going away.”

The FDA in January concluded a comment period exploring the issue of consumer confusion regarding the nutritional content of dairy products versus plant-based imitators, with organizations including the American Academy of Pediatrics offering evidence of nutritional deficiencies caused by confusion over the contents of plant-based versus dairy beverages while dairy’s detractors submitted thousands of off-topic creeds. After carefully considering comments and noting consumer survey data that clearly demonstrates confusion over nutrition, NMPF in February released its own road map offering solutions to how public health, product integrity and free speech could be protected through updated regulations. That Citizen Petition is currently open for comment.

NMPF also supports the DAIRY PRIDE Act, a potential legislative prod for FDA action.

###

The National Milk Producers Federation (NMPF), based in Arlington, VA, develops and carries out policies that advance dairy producers and the cooperatives they own. NMPF’s member cooperatives produce more than two-thirds of U.S. milk, making NMPF dairy’s voice on Capitol Hill and with government agencies. For more, visit www.nmpf.org.

#AlmondsDontLactate Social Media Contest

How to participate

In a Twitter or Facebook post, describe why it’s important that the FDA enforce its standards for milk and other dairy products. To be eligible to for a prize, use “#AlmondsDontLactate” on your post (NOTE: posts must be “public”, so the administrator is able to access).

 

Contest rules

  1. Winners will receive an “Almonds Don’t Lactate” t-shirt in their desired size, along with a few other dairy goodies.
  2. Winners will be selected from all valid entries. Originality and creativity of content will be considered during the selection process.
  3. Multiple entries are allowed.
  4. No purchase or payment of any kind is necessary to enter or win.
  5. The contest is not sponsored, endorsed or administered by, or associated with Twitter or Facebook.
  6. The giveaway is open to U.S. residents over 21 years of age.
  7. Entries must be posted by 11:59 PM EST Friday, July 19.

 

Content Restrictions:

  • The entry must not contain material that violates or infringes another’s rights, including but not limited to privacy, publicity or intellectual property rights, or that constitutes copyright infringement;
  • The entry must not disparage any person or party affiliated with the contest;
  • The entry must not contain material that is inappropriate, indecent, obscene, hateful, tortious, defamatory, slanderous or libelous;
  • The entry must not contain material that promotes bigotry, racism, hatred or harm against any group or individual or promotes discrimination based on race, gender, religion, nationality, disability, sexual orientation or age; and
  • The entry must not contain material that is unlawful, in violation of or contrary to the laws or regulations in any jurisdiction where the entry is created.

First DMC Payments Providing Critical Aid to Dairy Farmers in Need

 ARLINGTON, Va. – The National Milk Producers Federation thanked the U.S. Department of Agriculture for meeting the timeline Agriculture Secretary Sonny Perdue promised in February for dairy-program payments under the 2018 farm bill. Dairy farmers began receiving checks under the new Dairy Margin Coverage program this week, in keeping with USDA’s pledge.

“DMC aid represents significant improvement from previous programs, and with dairy farmers facing a fifth year of low prices, receiving better assistance in a timely fashion is a matter of survival for some family farms,” said Jim Mulhern, president and CEO of the NMPF.  “The DMC program doesn’t replace a healthy market, but it is a crucial safety net in turbulent times. All dairy producers should strongly consider enrolling, and to look closely at coverage at the $9.50 maximum level.”

More than one-fourth of all U.S. dairy farms – nearly 10,000 — have signed up for DMC since signups began June 17, according to USDA. Enrollment will continue through Sept. 20, and coverage is retroactive to Jan. 1. NMPF has a resources page on DMC and other dairy assistance programs on its website, https://www.nmpf.org/policy_tags/dairy-margin-coverage/.

###

 The National Milk Producers Federation (NMPF), based in Arlington, VA, develops and carries out policies that advance dairy producers and the cooperatives they own. NMPF’s member cooperatives produce more than two-thirds of U.S. milk, making NMPF dairy’s voice on Capitol Hill and with government agencies. For more, visit www.nmpf.org.

Results Matter, and the DMC Delivers

Getting results for members is central to the mission of any trade organization.

Fortunately, thanks to a great deal of hard work by our expert staff, NMPF has important achievements to point to that will make life better for the folks we serve.

One major accomplishment came to fruition in June, with signup beginning for the Dairy Margin Coverage program. This program will not only tangibly aid farmers struggling with low prices; it will help milk producers even more than we first reported when the farm bill that contained it was signed into law last December.

A quick recap: After the Margin Protection Program, an effort wounded out of the gate because of Congressional budget compromises from 2014, clearly showed it was inadequate for farmer needs, we went to work immediately in an effort to fix it. The effort took more than two years, but it paid off. First, by improving MPP in early 2018 budget legislation, then by replacing it with a better program in the farm bill late last year. The new DMC, along with other pro-dairy policies in the law, clearly outdoes previous initiatives, and we’re excited it’s finally becoming reality.

But even with the new law in place, we knew it wasn’t time for a victory lap — not with farmers still suffering from low prices and with more opportunities to solidify potential improvements to help members through the USDA rulemaking process. That set the stage for another accomplishment, one that finally reached fruition last month.

One farm-bill dairy provision we secured that was little-noted at the time, but that we knew had potential to further help producers, was a new requirement that USDA report the prices of higher-quality alfalfa feed in top dairy-producing states. We sought the provision in the farm bill because we knew the previous program’s feed-cost calculations did not fully reflect the true cost of dairy-quality hay. Obtaining the reporting provision in the farm bill was an opportunity to show more precisely the cost burden this feed was imposing on farmers. Calculations that best reflect industry cost-price fundamentals across the country is the spirit of the program, which is meant to help dairy farmers facing an income squeeze because of those higher feed costs.

We quietly made this case in meetings with USDA through the first half of the year — and it’s one that, thankfully, Secretary Perdue and the staff at USDA heard sympathetically. Less than a week before signups began June 17, USDA announced it would incorporate dairy-quality hay costs into DMC margin calculations.

The impact is immediate. Early this month, USDA reported that the May margin under the DMC program is $9.00 per hundredweight.  That reported margin is 12 cents lower than it would have been otherwise, meaning payments for farmers who enroll at the maximum $9.50 coverage level allowed under the program will be 12 cents higher because of the calculation change. For the first five months of 2019, hay values have averaged $0.21 cents/cwt. higher under the new formula. Again, participating dairy farmers will as a result of this change receive a greater payment, one many will need desperately in what is now our fifth year of low prices.

The DMC – now with its enhanced feed-cost calculation – is a tangible benefit for NMPF members as well as all the nation’s dairy farmers who sign up for the program. It came from the industry unity that was forged as we moved ahead on the farm bill, and it came from maintaining the discipline to focus on a realistic, achievable, dollar-and-cents return. It’s important to thank the many people who contributed to this effort: NMPF member cooperatives, numerous state dairy associations, IDFA, the lawmakers who drafted the farm bill, the administration officials who are implementing it – and the hard-working staff here who helped guide all of this into reality, and many more.

According to USDA, more than 5,300 producers enrolled in the DMC in the first 10 days of the sign-up period, with 98 percent of those who signed up for Tier I coverage of the first 5 million pounds selecting $9.50 coverage.  About half of all producers signed up for the full five-year length of the program. With checks going out in July, those who needed assistance immediately are receiving it, and those who are waiting for more information – or perhaps just a pause in their busy schedules – have until September. I strongly encourage all producers to take a good look at the new program and be sure to get into their county Farm Service Agency office to sign up.

Our efforts now are focused on providing resources and expertise to aid with signup, including on our website and through member communications, to make sure that farmers have the information they need to make the right decisions.

Like the dairy farmers we serve, our work is never done. But just as dairy delivers, that’s our goal too. A DMC that’s even better than it would have been is the kind of result we strive to achieve here every day at NMPF. We are proud to serve our members and the entire dairy producer community. Thank you for the hard work you do, which inspires us to do the same.

 

 

NMPF Welcomes New Trade, Regulation Staff

The National Milk Producers Federation continues to bolster its staff, adding experts in regulation and trade.

Miquela Hanselman, who interned last winter with NMPF trade staff, has joined the organization full-time as a manager for regulatory affairs. In this role she assists NMPF in its dealings with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, U.S. Department of Agriculture and the Environmental Protection Agency.  Specific topic areas include the National Council on Interstate Milk Shipments; food safety; raw milk legislation and regulation; labeling issues; nutrition policy, including the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, and environmental issues including air emissions. Hanselman grew up on a dairy farm in upstate New York and holds two degrees from Cornell University, a Master’s in Public Health earned this year and a Bachelor’s in Animal Sciences.

Tony Rice joins NMPF as our new Trade Policy Coordinator. In that role, he will work with NMPF’s Trade Policy team to advance the development, implementation and communication of NMPF’s work to support policies that promote U.S. dairy exports, to seek removal of policies that impede those exports and to address foreign barriers to U.S. dairy sales. NMPF does this work in concert with the U.S. Dairy Export Council. A native to Pennsylvania dairy, Rice is a former vice-president of the Pennsylvania FFA Association and this year earned a degree in Agricultural Business Management and Policy from Penn State University. He’s also interned at the White House and the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative.

NMPF Helps Shape Trade Strategy

The Agricultural Technical Advisory Committees (ATAC) for trade are tasked with providing guidance and technical advice to the USTR and USDA on trade negotiations. NMPF is pleased to share the recent announcement that NMPF’s Jaime Castaneda has been reappointed to the ATAC for Animals and Animal Products, along with John Wilson of Dairy Farmers of America, an NMPF member cooperative.

Castaneda and Wilson will play a valuable role through their continued service on the ATAC and their expertise and first-hand knowledge of the dairy industry will help the USTR and USDA develop effective trade strategies and objectives.

CWT-Assisted Export Sales Contracts Top 9 Million Pounds of Dairy Products

 CWT in June assisted member cooperatives in securing 51 contracts to sell 2.888 million pounds of American-type cheeses, 154,324 pounds of anhydrous milkfat, 257,941 pounds of butter, 5.407 million pounds of whole milk powder, and 566,588 pounds of cream cheese. The products will go to customers in Asia, Central America, the Middle East, Oceania and South America. The product will be shipped during the months of June through December 2019, to customers in 14 countries in five regions of the world.

These contracts bring the 2019 total of the CWT-assisted product sales contracts to 30.953 million pounds of cheese, 4.213 million pounds of butter, 35.640 million pounds of whole milk powder, 3.139 million pounds of cream cheese and 154,324 pounds of anhydrous milkfat. These transactions will move the equivalent of 669.376 million pounds of milk on a milkfat basis overseas.

Assisting CWT member cooperatives gain and maintain world market share through the Export Assistance program expands demand for U.S. dairy products and the U.S. farm milk that produces them. This helps all U.S. dairy farmers by strengthening and maintaining the value of dairy products that effect their milk price.

The amounts of dairy products and related milk volumes reflect current contracts for delivery, not completed export volumes. CWT will pay export assistance to the bidders only when export and delivery of the product is verified by the submission of the required documentation.

All cooperatives and dairy farmers are encouraged to add their support to this important program. Membership forms are available at http://www.cwt.coop/membership.

NMPF, Agriculture Groups Work to Keep Science in Scientific Standards

The Codex international food standards are meant to protect human health and establish fair trade practices by developing cohesive food safety standards for food and agricultural products. However, the mandate to base Codex international food standards on scientific fact may be up for debate in July.

The European Union and other countries are seeking to water down Codex’s scientific mandate and instead direct that nonscientific factors, such as consumer preference issues, be considered as Codex develops standards. This would have significant negative repercussions for the American dairy industry and its ability to challenge unscientific barriers to trade.

The Codex Executive Committee and Commission will meet at the beginning of this month to consider revising its procedures in light of EU pressure. NMPF is working with the U.S. Dairy Export Council to lead the charge against these changes and ensure that existing science-based Codex rules are enforced and followed to preserve a level playing field for U.S. exports. The outreach on this issue harnesses a united U.S. food and agricultural effort on this issue, including driving support for U.S positions at the meetings.

NMPF has joined with other leading U.S. agriculture groups to develop materials outlining this threat to share with policymakers and international stakeholders. Together with several of those groups and USDEC, NMPF staff met last month with USDA Undersecretary of Trade Ted McKinney and USTR Chief Agriculture Negotiator Gregg Doud to make the case as to why preserving the scientific structure of Codex is critical.

FARM Program Announces New Educational Resources

The National Dairy Farmers Assuring Responsible Management Program has released two new manuals and other materials as part of its FARM Workforce Development program area.

The FARM Safety Reference Manual provides straightforward, relevant and useful information on workplace safety and health meant to help dairy owners and employees develop and implement a robust and practical safety program. The FARM Safety Reference Manual is a collaboration between the Idaho Dairymen’s Association, the Idaho Milk Processors Association, and National Milk Producers Federation.

The FARM Human Resources Reference Manual helps dairy farm owners, managers and other relevant staff develop an on-farm HR program. An effective HR program supports a positive and safe work environment that helps attract and retain a professional, high-quality, and engaged workforce. A downloaded, customizable set of HR templates and a sample Employee Handbook accompany the FARM HR Manual.  The manuals can be found here. Spanish-language versions of the manuals and templates will be available soon.

The National Dairy FARM Program launched its newest component last year, gathering expert and stakeholder input from the entire dairy value chain, including farmers, cooperative staff, academics, and other subject matter experts. This input ensures the Workforce Development materials are technically robust and relevant to today’s dairy industry.

With the manuals complete, the FARM Workforce Development Task Force met on April 8 to discuss future program priorities:

  • Conduct a nationwide labor survey, implemented and analyzed by an academic institution. All data will be anonymous. The survey will provide robust, credible data to prove dairy’s labor story, especially in the face of misconceptions that exist outside of our industry.
  • Develop additional resources to support dairy producers, such as training videos and a safety ‘road map’. A breakout session at the Dairy Sustainability Forum in early May provided additional ideas and direction for useful resources.
  • Pilot an on-farm evaluation tool to help farms learn about HR and safety management best practices; identify which practices might be useful for their farm; and, track improvement over time. By performing on-farm evaluations, the industry can also provide important assurances to dairy customers, retailers, and brands.

FARM Workforce Development demonstrates that the U.S. dairy industry is proactive and passionate about providing safe and thriving work environments.

NMPF Farmer Leadership Meets with USDA on Important Animal Health Issues

Karen Jordan, DVM Chair of the NMPF Animal Health and Wellbeing Committee and NMPF staff met with USDA APHIS Administrator Kevin Shae and other USDA animal health leadership June 13 to discuss important animal-health issues for U.S. dairy farmers.

Dr. Jordan spoke about the importance of industry-government collaboration on preparedness for foreign animal diseases such as Foot and Mouth Disease. She commented on the need for USDA to modernize the FMD Vaccine Bank. “While there is always the promise for better vaccines in the future, now is the time to build a best-in-class FMD Vaccine Bank with the new funding provided by the 2018 Farm Bill,” she said. Jordan also stressed the need to maintain and enhance the Secure Milk Supply and the FMD Bulk Tank Milk Test.

Stakeholders also discussed domestic cattle diseases during the meeting. USDA is revising and updating its Bovine Tuberculosis Eradication Program Standards to meet the reality of the disease today. Jordan complimented USDA for its monthly teleconferences with the dairy and beef sectors and identified improving TB diagnostics as a priority for advancing TB eradication. The caudal fold test has outlived its usefulness for Test and Remove Protocol for dairy herds affected by TB.

Finally, Jordan expressed the importance of trade to U.S. dairy farmers. “More than 15 percent of U.S. milk is exported around the world, and APHIS leadership is necessary to maintain and enhance market access for U.S. dairy farmers,” she said. The important work that USDA APHIS does with Codex Alimentarius, the World Organization for Animal Health, and animal health certification for export certificates is vital for this, she said.